The Spiraling Chains: Kowalski - Bellan Family Trees
  • Home
  • Licciardi
    • Licciardi Family Photos
    • DeRigo
  • Bellan
    • Beljan Family in Croatia
    • Benicki >
      • Zagar
  • Bodziony
    • Bodziony - Poland
    • Golonka >
      • Bawołek
    • Krupa >
      • Kołodziej
  • Kowalski
  • The Spiraling Chains

On the Practicality of Marriage

9/16/2012

1 Comment

 
Picture
Earlier this past week, I read an article on NPR.org entitled "Can Marriage Save Single Mothers From Poverty."  The big statistic (as gathered from recent census data) is that a "third of families headed by single mothers is in poverty and they are four times more likely than married-couple families to be poor."  My initial reaction was "Well...duh."  Of course there is a better chance for a family to earn more money and be above the poverty level if there are two able-bodied workers in the home.  I read a few more articles from other news outlets and "traditional" family-oriented organizations that discussed the same statistic.  Not surprisingly, the more conservative, traditional family organizations hailed the institution of marriage as the obvious answer to solving the woes of families in poverty.  And, of course, that got the online comment and debate boards rolling.

In modern society, it's absolutely ridiculous to tell a single mom (or dad) to get married, or stay married in an unhealthy relationship, just to avoid poverty. (This is my opinion, but I think a lot of you would agree with me.)   And many of the online comments reflected how extreme this option seems in the 21st century.  How could you marry someone without being in love with them?  Why would you take vows to stay with a person forever just because it will help you economically?  And in today's world, it does sound absurd, BUT until relatively recently this WAS how single-parent families, especially those with young children, DID stay out of poverty. 

Let's go back, say, 150 years.  You live in a small rural farming community.  How did you meet your first husband?  At church?  Or maybe you attended the local schoolhouse together?  Perhaps your fathers farmed land adjacent to one another.  Considering how slow and difficult traveling long distances was at that time, most people tended to stay near their towns and most definitely within their home counties for their entire lives. 

The image below is a map of land owners in Wabash Twp, Darke County, Ohio in 1875.  My husband's great-great-great-grandparents were John Nicolas (J.N.) Grilliot and Mary Anne Aubry.  Just by looking at the map, you can see how (and why) the marriage came about.  ("S. Aubry" is Mary Anne's brother, Stephen, who inherited the land from their father when he died in 1873.  Stephen actually married one of John Nicolas's sisters.)

Picture
Portion of 1875 Wabash Twp, Darke Co, Ohio Land Ownership Map.
Marriages initiated by local neighborhood proximity were commonplace and even expected well into the 20th century, and not just in the rural areas.  The addresses of my grandparents on their 1939 Cleveland, Ohio marriage license are literally right around the corner from each other.  Of course, people still fall in love with and marry people they grew up with, but that phenomena is much less common than it used to be. 

Ok, so you are, say, 34 years old, living with your husband on your farm (which you may own outright or on which you may be paying a mortgage) and you have 6-7 kids.  What happens to your family should you or your husband suddenly die?  In a time when good hygiene and antibiotics didn't exist, disease and infection were all-too-common parts of life.  In the mid 19th century, women were 40 times more likely to die from childbirth-related complications than they are today.  Work-related accidents, whether on the farm or in a factory, took many parents' lives as well.  Life insurance did not exist and many families only scraped by as it was, so there was no savings to draw from.  There were no government-sponsored welfare programs; any assistance to families in distress originated from local neighbors and churches.

Widows and widowers with small children usually found it necessary to remarry in order to keep their families intact and to keep food on the table.  There were no such things as day care centers to watch the kids while mom or dad worked 12-14 hour days.  Occasionally, neighbors or extended family members could help, but nearly everyone had their own families to support and sometimes they could not handle that extra burden.  A struggling single parent would often be forced to send several of his/her children, some as young as nine years old, to live and work for other families as farmhands or house servants.  Even if they were able to stay at home, other children would be forced to quit school in order to work on the homestead or find a job in the community. 

The death of a parent forced my grandfather's family to split up temporarily.  My great-grandmother, a Polish immigrant, died suddenly of appendicitis in 1919 at the age of 29, leaving my great-grandfather with four sons between the ages of ten and five.  In the 1920 census, my great-grandfather and the two oldest boys are living with a cousin and the third boy is living with another family.  I cannot find my grandfather, the youngest, in this census, so I don't know where or with whom he was living.  My great-grandfather remarried in 1921, at which point I know the brothers were reunited.

Did all of these widows and widowers marry because they fell in love, or was it more because of the need to take care of their families?  Old marriage certificates can't tell us that, so we'll never know for sure.  It's unrealistic to expect single parents to do so today, but, if I ever did find out that one (or more) of my ancestors' marriages were for more practical reasons other than for love, I would not judge them or think less of them.  They did what they had to do for their families and their livelihoods.


©2014, copyright Emily Kowalski Schroeder

1 Comment
Meghan link
9/16/2012 07:43:27 am

Emily! I had no idea you were blogging. I really loved this post - I find anything historical fascinating, but I especially love family & social histories. I definitely agree that marrying to sustain a family economically was far more common and made a lot more sense many years ago. Can't wait to read more!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Emily Kowalski Schroeder

    Emily Kowalski Schroeder

    Archives

    April 2017
    March 2017
    August 2016
    July 2016
    August 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012


    Categories

    All
    Anniversaries
    Antoni
    Aubry
    Bellan
    Bernard
    Bernhold
    Birthdays
    Birth Records
    Blogging
    Bodziony
    Braun
    Brunswick
    Bulcher
    Catholic
    Cemeteries
    Census Schedules
    Civil War
    Conferences And Talks
    Cousins
    Death Certificates
    Decorating
    Dna
    Drees
    Editorials
    First Communion
    France
    Funeral Cards
    Galicia
    Germany
    Golonka
    Grilliot
    Heirlooms
    Holidays
    Homes
    Hut
    Immigration
    Italy
    Janning
    Kahlig
    Knob
    Kowalski
    Krupa
    Licciardi
    Magottaux/Magoto
    Mapping
    Marriage
    Military
    Obituaries
    Occupations
    Organization
    Parazzini
    Poland
    Research
    Rolfes
    Schools
    Schroeder
    Ship Manifests
    Sports
    Surnames
    Tips
    Travel
    Tumbusch
    Voisinet
    Watercutter
    Weather
    Weddings
    Wellerding
    Wilkens
    Wills
    Wimmers
    World War II
    World War II
    Yearbooks


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.